Press "Enter" to skip to content
SPONSOR

Stockholm Syndrome in Politics

The void that coagulates into an ideological condition.*

Karl Marx as Wotan, with a Valkyrie dressed in the colors of Sweden kneeling at his feet

It is curious how hostile, even truculent, the response of those who rush to defend their tormentors tends to be when the dispute is political.

Who defends a tormentor?

According to the American Psychological Association (APA), drawing on research, survivors of captivity may develop an unconscious bond with their captors, forming emotional ties such as sympathy, gratitude, loyalty, or even a defense of their actions. Typical signs include feelings of guilt, attempts to justify or minimize the aggressor’s behavior, distrust of or hostility toward those who try to help and, often, difficulty recognizing oneself as a victim.

Nils Bejerot, the criminologist and psychiatrist who assisted the police during a robbery at the Kreditbanken in Stockholm in 1973, coined the term, at first “Norrmalmstorg syndrome,” after the square where the bank stood. Four employees were held hostage for six days. Once freed, several of them refused to testify against the robbers, defended them publicly, and reportedly even raised money to pay for their captors’ legal defense. Outside Sweden, the phenomenon came to be known as “Stockholm syndrome,” and its clinical definition is usually credited to the American psychiatrist Frank Ochberg.

The void that coagulates into an ideological condition.*

To return to the subject: whenever the dilemma of state inefficiency comes up, it is not unusual for this syndrome to show its face. All it takes is for one side to propose a definitive solution to the obstacle. Put crudely, try suggesting that the Leviathan “doesn’t work and should be scrapped,” and witness, purely out of curiosity, the nervous complication that ensues. The same holds for criticism of the State as a whole and of its monopoly over public health, education, defense and security, urban planning, tree planting, sanitation, notarial bureaucracy, judicial mediation, and even the burying of overhead power lines.

Even when the deficiency inherent in any kind of government is acknowledged, inflamed postures tend to well up from the depths of some people’s unconscious. These are the hosts, asymptomatic until then, of a dependency. The first act usually takes the form of disqualifying the debate in advance, not to mention the nervous laughter. As a rule, it comes from those who, however classically liberal they may be, defend the State as a necessary evil (or good). What they actually maintain is that the problem should be solved by the problem itself.

It is in that moment of cold sweat that this metaphorical syndrome finds its trigger. Sometimes in a euphoric reaction. The reasons vary: from a lack of depth on the subject to material or institutional interest; from the laziness of reconsidering a whole life spent idling as this order’s hostage to the irrational comparison between a hypothetical hierarchical “void” and abyssal chaos.

Without going into the merits of the question, this disproportionate reaction has always struck me as intriguing. Even less theoretical, more everyday political debates, which by their practical nature ought to stir more immediate passions, do not provoke reflexes so quick. Nor a revulsion so instinctive.

Not long ago, this reflection came to me explicitly in a conversation with two people. One of them, ironically, was Swedish. I floated the trigger itself: “It has already proven it doesn’t work. It has to be scrapped!” I might say that, coming from a country known for its “welfare state,” the woman from Stockholm would naturally mount a feverish defense of the state machinery, its high taxes, and its spending of future generations’ money. The fervor, however, did not strike her alone: the other, a not especially committed classical liberal, joined the outbreak. What followed was an epidemic of merciless titters and the typical denials of someone already foaming at the mouth.

Defending the existence of the State is legitimate. For every argument, down to the final rounds, an equally legitimate rejoinder would stand ready. So why did the allergic reaction, expected as it was, come from both of them? However opposed their political and economic views, why such similar armor against my argument?

The reasons might be, as noted above, an amalgam of several conditions: unfamiliarity with the subject, laziness about reconsidering one’s own stance in life, confusion between the concepts of economics and those of fluid dynamics, or even an abyssal anxiety, which Kierkegaard also called “the dizziness of freedom” in The Concept of Anxiety (1844). If that is the answer, those who envision a way out of the impasse of the State’s tumorous unproductiveness have arduous work ahead. Persuading someone to change course midway through life’s journey is a Dantesque task, and the answers that follow do tend to summon reactions straight from the underworld. If freedom recalls the abyss, the reaction may conjure up Hell.

Setting aside cases of financial interest, which should be of interest to the police, and looking at it from another angle: if the hypothesis really is something like a syndrome, then the cure would begin with a psychiatrist.

*Note: this article is, of course, not a diagnosis. The syndrome describes the reaction of survivors of captivity and is used here only as a metaphor.

SPONSOR

SPONSOR